CELPIP Speaking Task 5, Comparing and Persuading, has two parts. In Part 1 you get 60 seconds to compare two options and choose one, and you do not speak. In Part 2 a new option appears that someone else prefers; you get 60 seconds to prepare and 60 seconds to persuade that person your choice is better. These timings come from the official CELPIP Speaking Pro: Target 9+ Study Pack 2026.
How long is CELPIP Speaking Task 5?
Task 5 is the only CELPIP Speaking task split into two screens, and the only one with a part where you say nothing at all.
| Part | What you do | Preparation time | Speaking time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Part 1 | Read about two options and choose one | 60 seconds | None (no speaking) |
| Part 2 | Persuade someone your choice beats their option | 60 seconds | 60 seconds |
Source: the revised 2026 Speaking study pack (Task 5 overview page). The task name matches CELPIP's test format page, which lists 8 Speaking tasks in about 15 minutes. In Part 2, when preparation ends the screen moves on by itself, you hear "Start speaking now", and recording starts automatically.
What does CELPIP Speaking Task 5 ask you to do?
In Part 1 you see two options, each with a picture and a few facts such as price, size or features. You pick the one you prefer. In Part 2, a third option appears: a family member, friend or coworker likes that one. Your job is to persuade them that your option from Part 1 is better than theirs.
The study pack's strategies boil down to six steps: understand the situation, compare the two options, choose quickly, read the new option, think of reasons your choice is better, and use specific language that goes beyond the information shown with the picture.
How should you choose in Part 1?
There is no "correct" option. The study pack simply tells you to choose the one you prefer to talk about, so pick the option you can say more about, not the one you would buy in real life. A quick test: can you name two clear advantages it has? If yes, choose it in the first 20 seconds and spend the rest of Part 1 looking at its details, because you will need them in Part 2.
How is CELPIP Speaking Task 5 scored?
Task 5 is not scored on its own: your Speaking level comes from all 8 tasks together. Each speaking performance is rated by three to five trained raters, and if their ratings disagree a benchmark rater is assigned (CELPIP test results page). Raters use the four dimensions of the CELPIP Speaking Performance Standards. The left two columns are CELPIP's; the right column is what each one means for this task.
| Dimension | Official factors | What it means here |
|---|---|---|
| Content/Coherence | Number, quality and organization of ideas; examples and supporting details | Two or three clear reasons, each with a detail; reasons in a logical order |
| Vocabulary | Word choice; suitable use, range, precision and accuracy of words and phrases | Comparison language (far cheaper than, whereas, in the long run) and precise words, not repeated prompt words |
| Listenability | Rhythm, pronunciation and intonation; pauses, interjections and self-correction; grammar and variety of sentence structure | Steady pace, natural stress on the key differences, mixed sentence types |
| Task Fulfillment | Relevance, completeness, tone, length | You talk to the person, compare against their option, sound persuasive and finish in time |
The study pack's Level 8 sample for this task is a useful warning. Its three ideas were relevant, but the analysis says it needed more examples and details, only used basic linking words, sounded flat for a happy business decision, and was cut off before the last idea ended.
CELPIP Speaking Task 5 template
Use this five-step structure. In 60 seconds that is roughly 130-150 words at a natural pace.
- Talk to them and acknowledge their option (1 sentence). "I can see why you like the sofa bed, but I really think the leather sofa is the better choice."
- Reason 1: your strongest difference. Compare directly and say what it means: "It's less than half the price, which leaves money for..."
- Reason 2: a second difference. Use a contrast word: whereas, on the other hand, unlike.
- Reason 3 or answer their reason. Why do they want their option? Show you heard it and offer another way to get that benefit.
- Close with a next step (1 sentence). "Let's book it tonight. What do you say?" Keep this short so you are never cut off.
In the 60-second prep for Part 2, write three keywords, one per reason (for example: winter / cost / time). Don't write sentences.
Useful comparison and persuasion phrases
- "It's a lot more practical than..." / "...is far cheaper in the long run."
- "Whereas the e-bike needs..., the pass..."
- "I know you're worried about..., but..."
- "Think about it this way:..."
- "The way I see it, we'd save..."
- "That's why I'm convinced... is the better fit for us."
CELPIP Speaking Task 5 practice questions
Ten practice situations written by our team. For each one, invent a few facts (price, size, distance) for the options before you start, then time yourself: 60 seconds to choose, 60 seconds to prepare, 60 seconds to speak.
| # | Situation | Part 1: choose between | Part 2: the other person prefers |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Your family is planning a long-weekend trip in August. | A lakeside cabin 3 hours away, $190/night, no Wi-Fi / a downtown hotel in a big city, $240/night, walking distance to museums | Your partner: tent camping in a provincial park, $35/night |
| 2 | Your team at work is planning its holiday party. | A sit-down dinner at a restaurant / an evening at a bowling alley with pizza | A coworker: a potluck in the office lunchroom |
| 3 | Your 9-year-old needs something to do in July. | A full-day YMCA day camp, $260/week / swimming lessons twice a week, $120/month | Your partner: two weeks with the grandparents in another province |
| 4 | Your family is buying its first home in Calgary. | A two-bedroom condo downtown / a townhouse in a suburb with a small yard | Your spouse: a detached house 45 minutes from the city |
| 5 | Your community centre has money for one new program. | Free English conversation circles for newcomers / a youth hockey equipment library | A neighbour: a community garden |
| 6 | You and your sister are buying a gift for your parents' 35th anniversary. | A weekend at a spa resort / a professional family photo session | Your sister: a new smart TV |
| 7 | Your small office has budget for one upgrade. | Standing desks for everyone / new laptops for everyone | Your manager: a two-day training course for the team |
| 8 | You are choosing a gym membership with a friend. | A big chain gym, $25/month, open 24 hours / a small studio, $60/month, classes included | Your friend: free outdoor running club and home workouts |
| 9 | Your brother is visiting Canada for two weeks in January. | A trip to the mountains to ski / a trip to see the Northern Lights | Your brother: staying in the city and visiting shopping malls |
| 10 | Your apartment building is choosing how to spend the repair fund. | New security cameras at the entrances / a renovated laundry room | A neighbour on the committee: repainting the hallways |
The study pack suggests recording one answer for each Part 1 option. That doubles your practice and stops you relying on one favourite argument. You can practise with real timers in our free CELPIP speaking practice test, which records in your browser.
CELPIP Speaking Task 5 questions with answers
Sample answer 1: transit pass vs e-bike (149 words)
Practice prompt (written by our team): Your workplace is 12 km from home and you need a better way to get there. Part 1 options: (A) a monthly transit pass, $115 a month, bus stop a 5-minute walk away, 45-minute ride; (B) a used hatchback, $9,000, plus about $200 a month for insurance and $100 a month for parking downtown, 20-minute drive. You choose the transit pass. Part 2: your spouse suggests an e-bike instead: $2,200, about 35 minutes each way, can be charged at home. Persuade your spouse that the transit pass is the better choice.
Sample answer aiming at CLB 9+, written by our team:
Honey, I can see why the e-bike appeals to you. It's good exercise and it's green. But for my commute, I really think the transit pass is the smarter option.
First, think about our winters. From November to March the bike lanes are icy, and some mornings it's minus twenty. On the bus I'm warm and safe, whereas on a bike I'd arrive at work frozen or soaked.
Second, look at the cost. The e-bike is twenty-two hundred dollars up front, and that's before a good lock, winter tires and repairs. The pass is a hundred and fifteen a month, with nothing to fix or store.
And finally, the bus gives me forty-five minutes to answer emails or read, so I start my day ahead instead of exhausted.
Let's get the pass for now, and maybe buy an e-bike next summer for weekend rides together. What do you think?
Why this answer works:
- Opens by naming their option and conceding one point, then states the choice. That sounds persuasive, not stubborn, which helps tone.
- Every reason is a comparison ("whereas on a bike...", "nothing to fix or store"), so the rater hears comparing, not just describing.
- Expands the facts given (winter, hidden costs of a bike) instead of reading the numbers back.
- Transitions are clear: first, second, and finally.
- The close offers a compromise and a question, so the call ends naturally inside 60 seconds.
Sample answer 2: used leather sofa vs sofa bed (143 words)
Practice prompt (written by our team): You and your roommate need a couch for your new apartment. Part 1 options: (A) a new three-seat fabric sofa from a furniture store, $1,200, free delivery in two weeks; (B) a used leather sofa listed online, $300, excellent condition, you pick it up this weekend. You choose the used leather sofa. Part 2: your roommate prefers a new sofa bed: $850, grey fabric, folds out into a double bed, delivery $90. Persuade your roommate that the used leather sofa is the better choice.
Sample answer aiming at CLB 9+, written by our team:
Hey Daniel, I know the sofa bed sounds practical for when friends visit, but hear me out, because I think the leather sofa is a much better deal.
The biggest thing is price. It's three hundred dollars, which is less than half of the sofa bed once you add the ninety-dollar delivery. That leaves us money for a rug and a decent lamp.
Second, leather is just easier to live with. If someone spills coffee, you wipe it off in seconds, whereas grey fabric would stain the first week.
And honestly, sofa beds are rarely comfortable as either a sofa or a bed. We have guests maybe twice a year, so we could buy a good air mattress for about sixty dollars instead.
My cousin has a truck, so we could pick it up on Saturday morning. Shall I message the seller now?
Why this answer works:
- Answers the roommate's real reason (guests) instead of ignoring it, then offers a cheaper fix. Handling the other side is what makes it persuasion.
- Turns numbers into meaning: "less than half... once you add delivery" shows the comparison rather than reciting prices.
- Varied, precise vocabulary: a much better deal, easier to live with, rarely comfortable as either.
- Friendly, confident tone suits a roommate, and the ending moves to action.
What are the most common Task 5 mistakes?
- Describing instead of comparing. "The pass is $115. The bus is warm." is a list. "The pass is $115 a month, whereas the bike costs $2,200 up front" is a comparison.
- Arguing against the wrong option. In Part 2 your opponent is the new option. Don't spend your time on the one you rejected in Part 1.
- Reading the numbers back. Raters want your own words and ideas. Turn facts into consequences: what does the price difference let you do?
- Talking about the person instead of to them. Say "you", use their name, and sound like a real conversation.
- Changing your mind halfway. Conceding one small point is fine; switching sides is not.
- Running out of time. Plan three reasons but be ready to drop the third and go straight to your closing line.
Other CELPIP Speaking tasks
This guide is part of our CELPIP Speaking tasks overview, which covers all 8 tasks. Previous task: Task 4: Making Predictions. Next task: Task 6: Dealing with a Difficult Situation. For the full plan to reach CLB 9, see how to get CLB 9 in CELPIP.
Get one-on-one CELPIP Speaking feedback
Recording yourself shows you what you said; a coach tells you why it scored the way it did. Usha Iyer gives personal one-on-one CELPIP coaching online, with feedback on every Speaking task. Book your free first class.